Are You Measuring Activity or Proving Cyber Readiness? Your Board Wants to Know the Difference.

Are You Measuring Activity or Proving Cyber Readiness? Your Board Wants to Know the Difference.

For years, leadership teams and boards have been conditioned to accept security reports filled with activity-based metrics. In an era of industrialized cyber attacks, where ransomware groups operate with corporate efficiency and a single breach can cost millions, this is no longer a tenable position. The nature of risk has changed, and with it, the nature of leadership.

It’s one of the most persistent and dangerous paradoxes in cybersecurity: an organization can pass every audit with flying colors, only to collapse when a real attack hits. We count the number of employees who completed their annual phishing training. We track the percentage of servers that were patched on schedule. We verify that policies were reviewed and signed. 

While these compliance checklists might provide some comfort, creating a neat paper trail of effort, they tell you nothing about actual preparedness. They also create a dangerously false sense of security.

A leader's fiduciary duty to the organization has evolved. It now includes demanding tangible, defensible proof of resilience. Regulators are no longer satisfied with policies on a shelf; mandates like the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) in the financial sector require firms to prove they can withstand and recover from attacks. Shareholders are asking pointed questions about cyber risk in earnings calls, and cyber insurance providers are demanding hard evidence of controls before they will even write a policy. 

The critical shift required is to go from measuring activity to proving capability. In cybersecurity, this means moving beyond who simply completed training and instead showing how well your people actually performed when faced with a realistic simulation of an attack. True readiness can’t be found in a policy document or a passing audit score. It must be demonstrated. It must be proven.

How do you make this shift? You put your plans, technology, and people to the test in the most realistic way possible. This is where you prove your readiness. By running live crisis simulations and cyber drills that mirror real-world threats—from ransomware to supply chain compromises—you can measure what actually matters in a crisis: the speed and accuracy of your team's decisions, the quality of their communication, and their confidence when the pressure is on . These are the true leading indicators of performance. 

A policy might say that the legal and technical teams must confer before isolating a server, but a live exercise will prove whether they can actually do it in under ten minutes when customer data is actively being exfiltrated and the C-suite is demanding answers. It tests the entire organizational response, from the SOC analyst who sees the first alert to the CEO who has to make the final call on a ransom payment.

The data generated from these exercises is invaluable. It moves you from the realm of assumption to the world of evidence. Now, you can answer the board's toughest questions with data, not just assurances. When they ask, "Are we ready for a ransomware attack?" you can respond not with "We have a plan," but with, "We ran a simulation last quarter against the latest ransomware TTPs. Our technical team detected the initial intrusion 15% faster than they did six months ago, and our executive team made the decision not to pay the ransom 30 minutes faster, saving us from significant operational disruption. Here are the areas we're now focused on improving."

This data forms the basis of a true, board-level metric—what we call a "Resilience Score." This score aggregates performance data from across your drills and exercises into an instant, understandable snapshot of your security posture. It’s a metric that can be tracked over time, showing real, quantifiable improvement in your organization’s ability to handle an attack. 

It replaces guesswork with an evidence-based, defensible position on your ability to resist, respond to, and recover. In today's threat environment, the logic is simple and unforgiving: if you can't prove you're ready, you must assume that you are not.

Ready to move beyond activity-based metrics and build a framework for proving readiness with data-driven evidence? Download our comprehensive whitepaper, A Leader's Guide to Proving Cyber Readiness, to get the playbook for satisfying your board, regulators, and insurers.

‍